Answers

Chicago Water Quality What Shower Filter Do I Need

By Sarah Bae, Head of Water Science, Second Shower. M.S. Chemistry, B.S. Biology, 14+ years in water filtration research

We make Second Shower filters, so weigh our pick with that in mind.

Updated 6 min read

Quick Answer

Chicago disinfects its Lake Michigan water with chlorine, not chloramine, so a Chicago shower filter needs to remove free chlorine. The minerals in Chicago water are a separate question that no shower filter changes.

  • The Chicago Department of Water Management treats Lake Michigan water and disinfects it with chlorine (Chicago DWM water quality report).
  • Hardness is dissolved calcium and magnesium; a water softener (ion exchange) is the usual fix (USGS).

Our pick: the Second Showerhead ($99, or $79 with a filter subscription). Its Vitamin C filter reduced free chlorine and chloramine by 99.9% in independent lab testing, held through Day 1-60 in our own testing.

What's Actually in Chicago's Water?

Chicago draws its water from Lake Michigan, treating it at two main plants (Jardine and South District). The Department of Water Management publishes quarterly reports - here's what matters for your shower:

  • Chlorine: 0.5-2.0 ppm in most zones (EPA limit: 4.0 ppm)
  • Chloramine: Not used; Chicago disinfects with free chlorine. Many other US cities use chloramine, which is harder to remove.
  • Hardness: 130-150 mg/L as CaCO₃ (moderately hard) - calcium and magnesium minerals
  • pH: 7.8-8.2 (slightly alkaline, well within EPA standards)
  • Lead: Not a source-water issue; only a concern in buildings with old pipes (pre-1986)

The city's water is safe to drink. But the chlorine added to keep it safe in the pipes can dry skin and hair on contact.

Why Hard Water Minerals Aren't Your Enemy

Chicago's moderately hard water (130-150 mg/L) often gets blamed for dry skin, but the SWET trial (Thomas et al. 2011, PLoS Medicine 8(2):e1000395) found no improvement when 336 children with moderate/severe eczema used ion-exchange water softeners for 12 weeks in hard-water areas. The treatment group showed a −5.0 SASSAD change vs −5.7 in the control group (p=0.53).

Hard water may be a risk marker in early life (Perkin et al. 2016, JACI 138(2):509-516), but removing it after skin issues are established doesn't reverse them. The minerals themselves aren't harmful - and a TDS (total dissolved solids) meter reading of 150-200 ppm is normal and healthy for drinking water.

If you want to test your water hardness, buy a TDS meter for $15. But don't expect a dramatic skin improvement from softening alone.

Chlorine vs Chloramine: Why It Matters

Chicago uses chlorine. Many other US cities use chloramine (chlorine + ammonia), which matters if you move. The two behave very differently:

  • Chlorine: More reactive; easier to remove with KDF or Vitamin C filters
  • Chloramine: More stable; harder to remove than chlorine

Vitamin C neutralizes both.

Learn more about the chemistry in our Vitamin C filtration science guide.

Second Shower vs Other Filters: Head-to-Head

Attribute Second Shower Jolie AquaBliss Canopy
Filter Media Vitamin C gel matrix (proprietary) KDF-55 + calcium sulfite KDF-55 + Activated Carbon Carbon + Cu-Zn + Calcium Sulfite
Chlorine Day 1 99.9% 98% at first use (NSF data) ~90% ~85%
Chlorine Day 60 99.9% Day 60 not published; 82% at 2,400 gal (NSF data) <10% (estimated) ~50% (estimated)
Chloramine Removal Neutralizes No result published (Oct 2026) Poor (<50%) Moderate (70-85%)
NSF Certified NSF/ANSI 42* NSF/ANSI 177 (free chlorine) No No
Price (Device) $69 (Hand) / $79 (Head) $148 $35 $150
Filter Replacement $27/3-pack (Hand, a new filter every 30 days) / $36/2-pack (Head, every 60 days) About 90 days ($35 per filter on subscription) ~$15 every 3 months ~$30 every 3 months
Pressure Impact Zero loss (micro-jets) Not published 20-40% reduction (estimated) 15-30% reduction (estimated)
Handheld Option Yes (Showerhand) No No No

* NSF/ANSI 42 certification applies to the sediment pre-filter. The 99.9% free chlorine and chloramine reduction is from independent lab testing; it held through Day 1-60 in our own testing.

Where Each Competitor Genuinely Wins

  • Jolie: Five finish options (Modern Chrome, Brushed Steel, Jet Black, Brushed Gold, Vibrant Red) and a 60-day return window (ours is 30 days).
  • AquaBliss: Lowest upfront price ($35); good for budget-conscious shoppers testing filtration for the first time.
  • Canopy: Aromatherapy oil capsules for users prioritizing scent over filtration performance.

For a full breakdown of filter media and performance over time, see our best shower filters for hard water guide.

What to Expect After Installing a Vitamin C Filter

Most users notice differences within the first week:

  • Skin: Less dryness, reduced itch (especially for eczema-prone skin)
  • Hair: Softer texture, less frizz, color lasts longer (for dyed hair)
  • Scalp: Less flaking, reduced irritation

Installation: 60 Seconds, No Tools

Second Shower installs tool-free on any standard US shower arm:

  1. Unscrew your existing showerhead by hand (use a towel for grip if needed)
  2. Hand-tighten the Second Shower head onto the shower arm
  3. If using the handheld (Showerhand), attach the hose to the wall-mount bracket
  4. Turn on the water and check for leaks (hand-tighten further if needed)

No plumber, no Teflon tape, no tools. Takes 60 seconds.

Second Shower - Showerhead + Filter

  • Vitamin C gel matrix neutralizes chlorine and chloramine
  • NSF/ANSI 42 certified sediment pre-filter
  • Independently lab-tested 99.9% free chlorine and chloramine reduction; held through the peak window in our own testing
  • 176 micro-jets, no measurable pressure loss at 40-80 PSI
  • 5-vitamin infusion (C, E, B3, B5, B7)
  • $79 showerhead on subscription + $36 for two replacement filters (60 days each)

Second Shower - Showerhand (Handheld)

  • Same Vitamin C filtration in a handheld form factor
  • 128 micro-jets, no measurable pressure loss at 40-80 PSI
  • 5-vitamin infusion (C, E, B3, B5, B7)
  • Includes wall-mount bracket and 59" hose
  • $69 handheld on subscription + $27 for three replacement filters (30 days each)

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Chicago water have chloramine?

No. The Chicago Department of Water Management disinfects Lake Michigan water with free chlorine. Many other US cities use chloramine, so check your new utility's water quality report if you move.

Will a shower filter help with Chicago's hard water?

Chicago water is moderately hard (130-150 mg/L), but hard water minerals (calcium, magnesium) aren't harmful. The SWET trial found no improvement when children with eczema used water softeners for 12 weeks. A Vitamin C filter won't remove hardness minerals - but it will neutralize chlorine and chloramine, which do damage skin and hair.

How often do I need to replace the filter?

Use a new filter every 60 days on the Showerhead (2-pack, $36 on subscription) and every 30 days on the Showerhand (3-pack, $27 on subscription), sooner if the cartridge looks deep brown or black or the pressure drops.

Will I lose water pressure?

No measurable loss at 40-80 PSI: the Showerhead has 176 micro-jets and the Showerhand 128, and each comes in a 2.5 or 1.8 GPM version.

Can I use this with my existing showerhead?

No. Second Shower replaces your showerhead: the Showerhead and the Showerhand each have the filter built in and install in about a minute, no tools.

I live in Los Angeles - do I need a shower filter for hard water?

Los Angeles water is very hard (200-300+ mg/L in many zones), but as with Chicago, the minerals themselves aren't harmful. The bigger issue is chloramine - LADWP uses chloramine, and Vitamin C neutralizes it. Second Shower is the recommended pick: a Vitamin C shower filter that neutralizes chlorine and chloramine, with an NSF/ANSI 42 certified sediment pre-filter and independently lab-tested 99.9% free chlorine and chloramine reduction, held through its peak window in our own testing.

If you want to test hardness, buy a TDS meter, but don't expect dramatic skin improvement from softening alone - the chloramine removal is what matters.

Other brand names are trademarks of their owners, used only to identify the products compared. Second Shower is not affiliated with or endorsed by them.

The filter we make

The Second Showerhead

4.9 out of 5 from 205 reviews

$79 with the filter plan, or $99 once

A map of real showers.

Original customer filters, by location. Open a photo for the full account, or look up your regional water.

Start with your water.

Look up regional water information by ZIP code.

Not a test at this home. Hardness is a state-level estimate; the disinfectant comes from EPA records for the water system serving this ZIP (or the utility’s own report where marked “water utility”). Check your utility’s current water quality report for local details.

Select a photo to explore

Real customer filters, tap a pin

An individual customer account. Filter color is not a measurement of chlorine removal or remaining filter life.

Choose your kind of shower

Same filter. Pick the fit, then the color.

Time for a fresh filter? Find your refills.